On The Big Bang Theory, Sheldon says something like, "That might well appear to be serendipitous to someone unfamiliar with the law of large numbers." Well, I have a passing familiarity with the law of large numbers, but I still find it serendipitous that a major paper on impact factors and citation patterns should come out in Science the day after my little blog post on journal impact factors in archaeology. Moreover, the paper comes from the laboratory of my favorite physicist, Albert-Lázló Barabasí, who in my opinion is producing some of the finest research in the current wave of social physics. His research has focused on power law distributions and scale free and fractal patterns in social phenomena, such as networks and human movement. He is also an alarmingly talented writer, as I have said before in this blog (see my August 21, 2010 post on his book Bursts).
The article that came out on Friday is
Wang, Dashun, Chaoming Song, and Albert-Lázló Barabasí (2013). Quantifying Long-Term Scientific Impact. Science Vol. 342, pp. 127-132. 10.1126/science.1237825.
The authors present a model that purports to predict the long-term impact of scientific articles. The model incorporates three factors: 1) preferential attachment--a positive feedback dynamic in which the increase in a quantity, such as wealth, citations, or social connections, grows for each individual in proportion to its already existing value, so that the rich get richer, highly cited papers accumulate even more citations, and the well-connected develop more associations. Preferential attachment is important because it is often invoked to explain the spontaneous emergence of power law distributions and scale free patterns. The distribution of citations has often been modeled as a power law, hence the logic of including preferential attachment as a process. 2) "Aging," which accounts for the decline in citations to an article over time. The authors show that when preferential attachment is controlled for by only considering papers with the same number of citation, the subsequent citations decay over time following a log-normal distribution. 3) "Fitness" is the third factor, defined as the "inherent differences between papers, accounting for the perceived novelty and importance of a discovery." This, of course, is difficult to measure because it is complex, intangible, and subjective, and it ultimately depends on the collective views of the scientific community.
The model seems to do a good job of describing citation patterns over time, both for individual papers and for journals. For example, given the first five years of citation data for a paper, the model predicts with considerable precision the next 25 years' of citations. If the first 10 years of data are used, the prediction improves markedly. A major novelty of the model is the incorporation of preferential attachment, which seems to account for its greater success compared to previously proposed models, which do not include a preferential attachment dynamic.
Removing preferential attachment from Barabasí's model yields a simpler, "lognormal" model that, like other existing models, works well for papers with small numbers of citations, but seriously under-predicts the long-term accumulation of citations. Another way of thinking of this might be that the dynamical process has two regimes. The first few (7 or 8) citations that a paper receives are subject to random effects, but after that preferential attachment kicks in and dominates the process of securing additional citations. This is not to say that the initial citations are truly random, but merely that the cumulative effects of the processes in total yield a match to a lognormally distributed random variable. Beyond the threshold, the citation process is dominated by different factors. For example, hypothetically, the first few citations to an article might come predominantly from articles in the same journal or closely allied ones, read by one community, but as citations accumulate the probability rises of being cited in journals with different audiences, which would exponentially increase the visibility of the article, thereby setting in motion the preferential attachment regime. This kind of explanation might even be tested.
The Wang et al. article set me to wondering whether we are nearing the day when one could engineer an article to be highly cited. I think the answer is still "no" because the critical part of the model is fitness, which remains a hot mess of imponderables. To address this, one could, hypothetically, pick the research topic of one's article through a social psychological analysis designed to identify a subject of optimal interest to the scientific community. I don’t know whether that is really possible, but I doubt it would be desirable. I fear it would preempt the element of serendipity that typifies most of the really significant and interesting scientific discoveries.
Showing posts with label Barabasi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barabasi. Show all posts
Monday, October 7, 2013
Saturday, August 21, 2010
Albert-Lazlo Barabasi's new book, "Bursts," and the problem with 'science writing'
While I was riding long-distance buses around Central America, I read Albert-Lazlo Barabasi's new book, Bursts. My friend, Larry Liebovitch, had recommended that I read Barabasi's first book, Linked, but I hadn't gotten around to it. Now I regret my oversight.
It's easy to say that Barabasi writes well for a physicist, but that doesn't do him justice. In truth, he writes well for a novelist. More impressive, the book has a complex novelistic structure with multiple storylines interwoven in a way that successfully builds the tension to climax and denouement. He combines a fascinating historical narrative with excellent science journalism about the work he's been doing on the timing of human activity and patterns of human movement, especially Levy flights. And he doesn't just report on the social physics as a reviewer, he went and interviewed the other physicists and provides all manner of human interest stories about them. I was entranced by some of the background stories about people I know, like Gene Stanley.
This is some of the best science writing I've ever read. The only things that even come close are John McPhee's writings and the book 1491. And Barabasi has the advantage of actually being a distinguished physicist who was involved in the original research, so there's no question that he understands the technical details and the intellectual issues. To this we have to add the advantage that he is a Hungarian from Transylvania. Why would this matter? Well, he chose to interweave throughout the book a remarkable historical narrative about Hungary and Romania from the sixteenth century, and since he's from that region, he was able to use a wide variety of primary and secondary sources in the original languages. The historical episode he traces--a Crusade nominally against the Ottomans in eastern Europe--is fascinating, and I'm surprised I didn't know anything about it.
The other book I brought with me couldn't have offered a sharper contrast. The Best of the Best American Science Writing was a disappointment. The book is a compilation of the essays from previously published collections of essays from the annual series The Best American Science Writing 2006, 2007, etc. As I read this book, I couldn't help but think, "When did the term 'science writing' come to mean dumbed-down human-interest features journalism about science?" With the exception of a few essays, such as Ernst Mayr's, almost all the stories were mere pablum, and in my opinion some were not even well written while others were wrong or, sadly, even anti-scientific. The scientific content of most of the essays was almost nil, and I don't think I have a blinkered view of what constitutes science. Forgive me for being old fashioned or narrow-minded, but I still think of "science writing" as reports or commentaries by scientists about original research. The current belief that actual scientific discourse is unreadable and needs to translated into some other genre is both false and deleterious because it deprives society of direct access to critical information and ideas. It is false because many scientists can write well and exert great effort to communicate clearly and creatively. So there isn't any need for translators who dumb stuff down. The portrait of the scientist as illiterate is as false as any stereotype. The average scientist is probably an average writer, and since science is an international collaboration, many scientists who publish in English are writing in a second language, which doesn't make for great prose. In addition, good writing is not usually a key criterion for publication in science journals. Nevertheless, hundreds of thousands of original scientific articles are published each year, and in that thick forest there are many beautiful trees: well-written, interesting, and intellectually significant essays. Why no one publishes an anthology of those, I don't know. In support of my argument, I only need to point to Barabasi's book. He's a physicist, for heaven's sake, perhaps the most impenetrable of the sciences. English must not be his first language. It might be his third or fourth. His work is largely mathematical. How could he write a book of general interest about it? But he has. And the book makes intellectually important points that his peer-reviewed articles don't. Only in the book does he describe the broader significant of his research and reveal that it is an organized program of investigation. The individual articles only hint at these broader themes.
So, if any publisher out there wants to start a series of the best of real science writing, let me know. I'd be happy to edit the first volume or two. Click on the title of this post to go to the Amazon page for Barabasi's book.
PS. My admiraton for Barabasi's book has nothing to do with the fact that he cited my Levy flights article! I swear.
It's easy to say that Barabasi writes well for a physicist, but that doesn't do him justice. In truth, he writes well for a novelist. More impressive, the book has a complex novelistic structure with multiple storylines interwoven in a way that successfully builds the tension to climax and denouement. He combines a fascinating historical narrative with excellent science journalism about the work he's been doing on the timing of human activity and patterns of human movement, especially Levy flights. And he doesn't just report on the social physics as a reviewer, he went and interviewed the other physicists and provides all manner of human interest stories about them. I was entranced by some of the background stories about people I know, like Gene Stanley.
This is some of the best science writing I've ever read. The only things that even come close are John McPhee's writings and the book 1491. And Barabasi has the advantage of actually being a distinguished physicist who was involved in the original research, so there's no question that he understands the technical details and the intellectual issues. To this we have to add the advantage that he is a Hungarian from Transylvania. Why would this matter? Well, he chose to interweave throughout the book a remarkable historical narrative about Hungary and Romania from the sixteenth century, and since he's from that region, he was able to use a wide variety of primary and secondary sources in the original languages. The historical episode he traces--a Crusade nominally against the Ottomans in eastern Europe--is fascinating, and I'm surprised I didn't know anything about it.
The other book I brought with me couldn't have offered a sharper contrast. The Best of the Best American Science Writing was a disappointment. The book is a compilation of the essays from previously published collections of essays from the annual series The Best American Science Writing 2006, 2007, etc. As I read this book, I couldn't help but think, "When did the term 'science writing' come to mean dumbed-down human-interest features journalism about science?" With the exception of a few essays, such as Ernst Mayr's, almost all the stories were mere pablum, and in my opinion some were not even well written while others were wrong or, sadly, even anti-scientific. The scientific content of most of the essays was almost nil, and I don't think I have a blinkered view of what constitutes science. Forgive me for being old fashioned or narrow-minded, but I still think of "science writing" as reports or commentaries by scientists about original research. The current belief that actual scientific discourse is unreadable and needs to translated into some other genre is both false and deleterious because it deprives society of direct access to critical information and ideas. It is false because many scientists can write well and exert great effort to communicate clearly and creatively. So there isn't any need for translators who dumb stuff down. The portrait of the scientist as illiterate is as false as any stereotype. The average scientist is probably an average writer, and since science is an international collaboration, many scientists who publish in English are writing in a second language, which doesn't make for great prose. In addition, good writing is not usually a key criterion for publication in science journals. Nevertheless, hundreds of thousands of original scientific articles are published each year, and in that thick forest there are many beautiful trees: well-written, interesting, and intellectually significant essays. Why no one publishes an anthology of those, I don't know. In support of my argument, I only need to point to Barabasi's book. He's a physicist, for heaven's sake, perhaps the most impenetrable of the sciences. English must not be his first language. It might be his third or fourth. His work is largely mathematical. How could he write a book of general interest about it? But he has. And the book makes intellectually important points that his peer-reviewed articles don't. Only in the book does he describe the broader significant of his research and reveal that it is an organized program of investigation. The individual articles only hint at these broader themes.
So, if any publisher out there wants to start a series of the best of real science writing, let me know. I'd be happy to edit the first volume or two. Click on the title of this post to go to the Amazon page for Barabasi's book.
PS. My admiraton for Barabasi's book has nothing to do with the fact that he cited my Levy flights article! I swear.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)